MLB The Show 23: The Captain Edition
Xbox One · 2023
About this game
The MLB The Show 23 Captain Edition on PlayStation includes:
A copy of the full game for PlayStation 5 and PlayStation 4
↓ Read more
New Era MLB The Show 9FIFTY limited edition cap
Limited edition SteelBook
Four days early access
Double daily login rewards (for the life cycle of MLB The Show 23)
Additional digital items:
Captain’s Choice Pack (x1)
To be announced Choice Pack (x1)
To be announced Uniform Choice Pack (x1)
Gold Choice Packs (x2)
Derek Jeter Cover art bat skin (x1)
About Xbox One
Microsoft's Xbox One launched in 2013 alongside the PS4 and leaned heavily into backwards compatibility and subscription services like Game Pass. Because so many Xbox One owners moved to all-digital libraries, physical Xbox One cartridges — sorry, discs — in good condition are comparatively less common on the secondhand market than their PlayStation equivalents from the same era.
Gamevaro tracks MLB The Show 23: The Captain Edition for Xbox One with separate market values for loose, complete-in-box (CIB) and factory-sealed copies, sourced from real eBay sales. Prices also vary by region — PAL, NTSC-U and NTSC-J releases of the same game often sell for different amounts due to print run sizes and regional collector demand.
Adding MLB The Show 23: The Captain Edition to a Gamevaro collection takes seconds — search by title or scan the box barcode, and the app fills in cover art, release details and current pricing automatically. This XONE release dates back to 2023.
Market values by condition
PAL
NTSC-U
NTSC-J
Recent sales
| Date | Type | Region | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-08-09 | Loose / Item only | PAL | €72.18 |
| 2026-08-08 | Loose / Item only | NTSC-U | €60.23 |
| 2026-08-08 | Loose / Item only | NTSC-J | €60.19 |
Market insights
Rarity & condition
Only a handful of market sales have been tracked for MLB The Show 23: The Captain Edition, suggesting it doesn't trade hands very often — a sign of relative scarcity compared to more common Xbox One titles.
Complete-in-box (CIB) copies typically command a premium over loose cartridges/discs because the original box and manual are more fragile and get discarded or damaged over time — fewer complete sets survive.
Frequently asked questions
How much is MLB The Show 23: The Captain Edition worth?
MLB The Show 23: The Captain Edition for Xbox One is currently worth €72.18 loose. Prices are based on real sales and update regularly on Gamevaro.
Is MLB The Show 23: The Captain Edition rare?
MLB The Show 23: The Captain Edition has only a handful of tracked market sales, suggesting relative scarcity compared to more common Xbox One titles.
What's the difference between loose, CIB and sealed for MLB The Show 23: The Captain Edition?
Loose means cartridge or disc only, CIB (complete in box) includes the original box and manual, and sealed means factory-sealed and never opened. These are tracked as separate market values because the price gap between them can be significant, especially for older releases.
Is MLB The Show 23: The Captain Edition worth more in PAL or NTSC?
The PAL version of MLB The Show 23: The Captain Edition is currently worth €72.18 loose, versus €60.23 for NTSC-U. Regional price differences usually come down to print run size and regional collector demand.
Ratings & Reviews
More Xbox One games
![Forza Horizon 3 [Ultimate Edition] (XONE)](/covers/xbox-one/187055.webp)
![Dark Souls Trilogy [Steelbook Edition] (XONE)](/covers/xbox-one/195288.webp)
